Path

Sherlock Holmes on Screen

A curated tour of Holmes on film and TV, in release order, one section per adaptation. These are separate takes, not one story. Tiers follow how highly critics rate each one as a Holmes adaptation, with Jeremy Brett and Basil Rathbone at the top.

0 of 13 watched · 46h 8m left

Sign in to track your progress

3 of 13 left (13h 19m) are on Hulu.

1 of 13 left (1h 44m) are on Paramount+.

5 (24h 6m) are free to watch.

4 aren't on any service Arcline knows (they may be elsewhere, or rent/buy only).

  1. Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce (1939–46)0 of 3 · 3h 59m
    1. Next · Stop 1The Hound of the BaskervillesFilm · 1939 · 1h 20m · essential

      Rathbone's first outing and the film that fixed the classic screen image of Holmes and Watson.

      Not on a streaming service we know.

      All options
    2. The second Fox film, a period piece against Moriarty, and the last before the series moved to Universal.

    3. Often picked as the best of the twelve Universal films: a foggy Canadian village and a string of killings.

    4. 1 optional hidden at Recommended

  2. Billy Wilder's Holmes (1970)0 of 1 · 2h 5mOpen
    1. Wilder's wistful, funny look at the man behind the legend, loved by Holmes fans.

  3. Jeremy Brett, Granada TV (1984–94)0 of 4 · 22h 52mOpen
    1. The Adventures, with David Burke as Watson, close to the stories and widely called the definitive Holmes.

    2. The rest of The Adventures, ending with Holmes's clash with Moriarty.

    3. The Return begins, with Edward Hardwicke taking over as Watson.

    4. Includes the feature-length Sign of Four and Hound of the Baskervilles.

    5. 3 optional hidden at Recommended

  4. Guy Ritchie's films (2009–11)0 of 1 · 2h 9mOpen
    1. Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law as a brawling, bantering pair, with action first and deduction second.

    2. 1 optional hidden at Recommended

  5. BBC Sherlock (2010–17)0 of 3 · 13h 19mOpen
    1. Benedict Cumberbatch and Martin Freeman in present-day London, with three feature-length episodes per series.

    2. Often called the show's peak, with new spins on three famous stories.

    3. 2 optional hidden at Recommended

  6. Mr. Holmes (2015)0 of 1 · 1h 44mOpen
    1. A quiet, moving film with Ian McKellen as a 93-year-old Holmes trying to recall his last case.

Quick answers

What is in Sherlock Holmes on Screen?
16 films and 13 seasons of TV.
How long does Sherlock Holmes on Screen take?
Essentials: 6 stops, 27h 9m. Recommended: 13 stops, 46h 8m. Everything: 29 stops, 107h 37m.
Where do I start?
Start with The Hound of the Baskervilles (1939). The last stop is Mr. Holmes.
What can I skip?
6 stops are essential. 7 more are recommended. 16 are optional: extras you can leave out.
Where can I watch Sherlock Holmes on Screen?
In the US, of the 13 stops at Recommended: 3 are on Hulu, 1 is on Paramount+, 5 are free to watch and 4 are not on a streaming service Arcline knows (they may be to rent or buy).

Images and where-to-watch data from TMDB and JustWatch. Title links and prices from Movie of the Night.

Keys

J K
Next or previous stop (also ↓ ↑)
W
Watch the selected stop
F
Mark it watched
/
Search
Esc
Close a sheet
?
This list